EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20503
STATEMENT OF ADMINISTRATION POLICY
(THIS STATEMENT HAS BEEN COORDINATED BY OMB WITH THE CONCERNED AGENCIES.)
March 8, 2000
HR 3833 - Minimum Wage Increase
(Shimkus (R) Illinois)
H.R. 3832 - Small Business Tax Fairness Act
(Archer (R) Texas)
If Congress presents the President with legislation that either unacceptably delays a minimum wage increase or contains fiscally irresponsible tax cuts, the President will veto the legislation.
H.R. 3833 - Minimum Wage Increase
Congress should pass a straightforward bill to raise the minimum wage by $1 in two equal steps, as proposed by the President. H.R. 3833, which would extend a minimum wage increase over a three-year period, would unacceptably delay the American worker's much-needed pay raise, costing a full-time, year-round worker more than $900 over two years. The Administration strongly urges Congress to enact a minimum wage bill as proposed by the President, unencumbered by measures that repeal important overtime protections for workers or regressive, fiscally irresponsible tax cuts that threaten Social Security, Medicare, and debt reduction.
A modest increase in the minimum wage of $1 would merely restore the real value of the minimum wage to the 1982 level. Recent history has shown that those who argue that even a reasonable increase in the minimum wage would harm the economy are wrong. Since the last minimum wage increase of 90 cents over two years, enacted in 1996, the unemployment rate has fallen from 5.2 percent to 4.1 percent -- around the lowest in 30 years -- and more than 10 million new jobs have been created. That last minimum wage increase provided a significant incentive to work, contributing to the 44 percent decline in the welfare caseload, and bringing the welfare rolls down to their lowest level in three decades. It also has been a crucial factor in contributing to rising incomes for even the poorest groups, reversing their income declines of the previous decade.
Minimum wage legislation should not be used as a vehicle to repeal important overtime protections for American workers, and the Administration would oppose adding such provisions. For example, the Administration is concerned about provisions in the bill that would repeal overtime protections for 1.5 million American sales employees, funeral workers, and computer professionals.
H.R. 3832 - Small Business Tax Fairness Act
By spending a substantial fraction of the non-Social Security surplus without a balanced framework, the House tax package would threaten the Federal Government's ability to extend the life of Medicare and Social Security and pay down the debt by 2013. Absent an agreement on a balanced framework, a bill composed of these provisions would not meet the pay-as-you-go requirements of the Budget Act, which have helped provide the discipline necessary to bring us from an era of large and growing budget deficits to the potential for substantial surpluses. The bill in its present form contains tax cuts of such magnitude that they would require an unacceptably large automatic sequester of mandatory programs, including Medicare.
The bulk of the tax provisions in H.R. 3832 are directed away from working families, and, whatever their stated intent, would do little to help most small businesses or family farms. For example, the estate tax relief is expensive, provides no benefit to average working Americans, and is poorly targeted to its purported purpose of providing relief for small business owners and family farms, because its three major provisions -- conversion of the unified credit to an exemption, repeal of the surtax, and reduction in top marginal rates -- would provide a disproportionate benefit to the very wealthiest estates.
H.R. 3832 also contains pension provisions that would raise the maximum retirement plan contribution and considered compensation limits for business owners and executives. This provision would weaken the pension anti-discrimination and top-heavy protections for moderate- and lower-income workers. These provisions are regressive, would not significantly increase plan coverage or national savings, and could lead to cuts in retirement benefits for moderate- and lower-income workers while benefits for highly paid executives are maintained or even increased.
The Administration urges the Congress to refrain from passing either a minimum wage increase that would be delayed unacceptably or fiscally irresponsible tax cuts that would threaten Social Security, Medicare, and debt reduction, and are not targeted at the needs of working families. The Congress should pass clean legislation that would raise the minimum wage by $1 over two years and that would increase the rewards for work in a manner that would be good for the country and good for working families who are struggling to make ends meet. The legislation should not be encumbered by provisions that are unrelated to this increase or that would undermine existing labor protections. And any tax bill passed by the Congress should be fiscally responsible and adhere to a framework that protects the Federal Government's ability to extend the life of Medicare and Social Security and pay down the debt by 2013, such as the Democratic alternative does.